Skip to content
December 12, 2012 / benrovik

Book Review: City of Masks by Mike Reeves-McMillan


SNAP JUDGMENT: An intriguing mystery in a beautifully inventive setting, written in a high literary style.

THE SETUP: Gregorious Bass is an honest, harmless nobleman who’s a nobody in his courtly home nation of Calaria. His master appoints him as envoy to the city-state of Bonvidaeo, a position that should be safe and low-stakes.

Bass comes to rely heavily on his Bonvidaoan manservant in his new home, however, because of the city’s odd custom: every person must wear a mask at all times. The masks not only reflect the character and social role of the person behind them, they shape how the person can act, speak, and think, in public and private. Acting counter to your own mask is a great crime.

But murder is an even greater crime, and when a mysterious figure in the mask of a Butcher kills one of Bass’s countrymen, his supposedly safe job puts him at the center of a deadly mystery…

REVIEW: Reeves-McMillan absolutely nails the elevated Gothic style of this novel. It’s told as succession of journal entries, like Bram Stoker’s Dracula. There’s even a one-act play embedded as a found narrative. The author’s command of language is fantastic, so the loquacious eighteenth-century narration is still appealing to a modern reader. The different narrators have very different voices– Celia’s motormouth journaling is especially fun– which provides nice variety.

In a speculative fiction book like this, with an intricate society, it’s indispensable to have a character like Bass as protagonist, who needs to learn the rules of his new home the same way the reader does. The rules of mask etiquette are detailed and internally consistent, and shape everything about the plot. But there is still a plot, and an exciting one; the book’s not just an excuse to pontificate about an alternate society.

This book has all the twists and revelations you’d expect from a story of courtly intrigue, and all the mistaken identities you’d expect from a story where everyone wears masks. There are thoughtful themes about identity woven throughout.

I listened to this as a free audiobook on, and loved Reeves-McMillan’s subtle delivery and choice of music. His Kiwi accent was lots of fun to my American ears, and helped establish the courtly atmosphere for me.

Strongly recommended!

Get the ebook of City of Masks today! Or listen to the free audiobook narrated by the author, and leave him a donation!

Contact Blog Twitter Facebook


Leave a Comment
  1. Catana / Dec 12 2012 5:35 pm

    I remember this story from quite a while back. Maybe a short version on the author’s website? It’s been a long time. Anyway, thanks for reviewing it. I’ve bookmarked it.

    • benrovik / Dec 12 2012 5:44 pm

      Yeah; Amazon reports that the ebook came out in 2006, and the podiobook is more than four years old too. Mike’s more recent books– like Gu– are definitely on my radar.

      • Catana / Dec 12 2012 5:58 pm

        That far back? Wow! Even though I’d completely forgotten about it, at least the memory stuck in my head. It’s also on Smashwords, which is where I bookmarked it. Guaranteed no DRM, I can download it in whatever format I want, and the author gets a bigger cut. I never buy ebooks from Amazon unless that’s the only version. Prefer Smashwords or the author’s own site, if they have one. There’s a definite trend of books that were published for free somewhere on the web being turned into ebooks, some of them very good.

      • benrovik / Dec 12 2012 7:39 pm

        I’m a fan of Smashwords too. All my books are there, except for the latest novella, “Aloft,” with which I’m testing out the KDP Select program. Here’s a link to City of Masks on Smashwords!

  2. Mike Reeves-McMillan / Dec 13 2012 3:21 am

    Thanks for the review, Ben. Glad to see our fandom is mutual.

    • benrovik / Dec 13 2012 4:24 am

      My pleasure! The book was a blast to listen to. Plans to do any more podiobooks?

      • Mike Reeves-McMillan / Dec 13 2012 8:26 pm

        I’m definitely thinking of doing a Podiobook for the first Gryphon Clerks book. I can hear the main female character’s voice in my head already.

  3. selfpublishingadvocate / Dec 13 2012 11:44 am

    Reblogged this on Self Publishing Advocate.

    • benrovik / Dec 14 2012 7:29 pm

      Many thanks! I’m following your posts too.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

<span>%d</span> bloggers like this: